Philosophers of biology challenge evolutionary psychologists on both of these points. Bateson, P.
Evolutionary Psychology Phil Papers: The hypotheses evolutionary psychologists generate, given that they are usually hypotheses about our psychological capacities, are tested by standard psychological methods. Singh claims that the detection and preference suite are adaptations for choosing fertile mates. For Richardson, most of evolutionary psychology falls in that category. I can reject bad science in the form of evolutionary and genetical claims about behavior; it does not imply that I think evolution played no role in our brains.
Philosophers take two main approaches to using empirical results in moral psychology. While it is true that evolutionary functional analysis can lend itself to just-so story telling, this is not the most interesting problem that confronts evolutionary psychology, several other interesting problems have been identified.
There has to be something more to it than just an academic defense of a discipline. Myriad versions of each of these arguments appear in the literature and many arguments for massive modularity mix and match components of each of the main strands of argumentation. If modules have all the characteristics that Fodor 1983 first presented, then he may be right that central systems are not modular.
Wiley, Hoboken, NJ. When in doubt, just question the motives of evolutionary psychology critics facebook twitter reddit linkedin email print.
And there is, unfortunately. The same goes for psychological mechanisms; they arise as responses to specific contingencies in the environment and are selected for to the extent that they contribute to the survival and reproduction of the organism.
The functional decomposition is driven by the response to specific environmental stimuli. Our successful navigation of the world results from the action of one or more of our many modules. In spite of such minor flaws, the book is an important addition to the literature on evolutionary psychology.
Scarborough and S. Evolutionary psychology rests upon specific theoretical principles presented in section 2 below not all of which are shared by others working in the biology of human behavior Laland and Brown 2002; Brown et al.
In the following section I take up discussions about evolutionary psychology in the philosophy of mind, specifically focusing on the debate about the massive modularity thesis. Meynell, L. Psychological Inquiry , Vol. Lewontin, R.
It is important to point out that evolutionary psychology is not a scientific non-starter like, say, homeopathy or intelligent design.
Evolutionary Psychology 5. Sinnott-Armstrong, W. Hagen, E. His " theory " essentially asserts Jewish biological superiority , but turns this around and uses it to argue that anti-Semitism is justified as "self-defense.